Is there a penalty for not performing Saee’ in the state of Wudhu? 

Q. I understand that a person should be in the state of Wudhu whilst performing Tawaaf and Saee of Umrah. But what if a person performs Umrah Tawaaf with Wudhu and Umrah Saee without Wudhu? Is there a penalty for performing Umrah Saee without Wudhu?

A. It is not a condition for a person to be in the state of Wudhu whilst performing the Saee’ of Umrah. Therefore, if a person performed the Tawaaf of Umrah with Wudhu and the Saee’ of Umrah without Wudhu, the Saee’ will be valid and there will be no penalty for it. (Al Barur Raaiq 3/23)

Allah Ta’ala Knows Best

Mufti Ismaeel Bassa

themufti.com